In March 1958 the United States launched Vanguard 1, a satellite the size of a grapefruit with two radio transmitters. One ran on a battery and went silent after about 20 days. The other ran on six small solar cells and kept transmitting for more than six years.
Solar cells then cost more than $3,000 a watt in today's dollars. That was only worth paying if you were building a satellite, where nothing else could keep it powered for years. A solar panel made in China now sells for about 12 cents a watt.
Solar got there with a playbook for beating a dirty industry, and it never needed anyone to care about the climate. Electric cars have followed it too. Protein made by fermentation has started down it and got stuck, for reasons I'll come back to at the end.
Start where it's worth the most
A new technology tends to start out expensive or limited, so it needs buyers who value it more than the old thing. For solar that meant satellites, and then places far from the grid, like lighthouses and oil rigs. Rooftops came decades later.
Tesla's first car was the Roadster, a sports car that cost about $100,000. In 2006 Elon Musk wrote the plan down in a blog post called "The Secret Tesla Motors Master Plan (just between you and me)": build a sports car, use the money to build an affordable car, then use that money to build an even more affordable one. Tesla is now worth more than any other carmaker in the world.
The first buyers' money pays for the next, bigger factory, and each bigger factory makes the product cheaper.
What only a government can do
Plenty of new technologies win without any help. Nobody had to subsidise the digital camera. A parent with one of the first digital cameras could take fifty photos at a birthday party and delete the blurry ones on the spot, without paying for a single roll of film. That was worth paying extra for, so early buyers did, and their money built bigger factories that eventually made digital cameras cheap. Today film is mostly a hobby.
Solar had a harder fight. A kettle boils just as fast on solar power as on coal power. Solar's advantage is that it doesn't pollute the air to do it, but the neighbours breathe that cleaner air too, without paying a cent. Most people weren't willing to pay more for that. To win them over, solar had to be cheaper than coal.
The mechanic down the street has to pay to get rid of their waste oil. Coal power stations have dumped their waste into everyone's air for more than a century without paying anything, and that keeps their electricity cheap. Early buyers of solar couldn't pay for enough factories to match coal's price.
Nobody pays for the footpath outside their own house. The council builds every footpath in the street out of everyone's rates. Clean air works the same way, so getting from a niche to the mass market often needs a government to guarantee demand and help fund the factories. In The Problems Nobody Pays to Fix I wrote about Germany. From 2000, its power companies had to buy electricity from anyone with solar panels at a fixed price, well above the market rate, for twenty years, and the extra cost went onto everyone's power bills. A household that put panels on the roof knew what they would earn, so many did, and that gave the young industry a large and reliable market. China went further and paid for the factories themselves, with cheap loans and subsidies, and it now makes more than 80 per cent of the world's solar panels. In 2010 the US government lent Tesla $465 million to build its first mass-produced car, and Tesla paid it back nine years early.
A government can also make the incumbent pay for the harm it does, or at least stop paying it to do harm. The IMF estimates that governments spent about $725 billion keeping fossil fuels cheap in 2024. Many cap what fuel companies can charge for petrol, diesel and electricity, then pay them the gap between that price and what the fuel actually costs. Cheap fuel is popular, and governments that have tried to end it have faced protests, from Nigeria in 2012 to Kazakhstan in 2022.
Once you add the cost of the air pollution and warming climate that the industry was never charged for, the IMF puts the total subsidy to fossil fuels at $7.4 trillion. Only a government can add that cost to the price, with a carbon tax or by making polluters buy a permit for every tonne they emit.
A 2015 study in Science looked at the places that had managed to put a price on carbon and argued that the way to get there is to pay to grow clean industries first, the way Germany did with solar, because those industries then have a stake in backing a carbon price.
But incumbents fight back. In 2014 Ohio froze its renewable energy targets, and a 2020 book on US clean energy laws traces setbacks like that mainly to utilities and fossil fuel companies. The industry a policy builds can't always defend it alone, so it helps to give the incumbents a stake in the replacement. In 2008 Denmark's state-owned energy company, DONG Energy, made 85 per cent of its heat and power from fossil fuels. It moved into offshore wind, sold its oil and gas business in 2017 and renamed itself Ørsted. By 2019 it was the world's biggest producer of offshore wind power.
All of this is politics, and policies like these get made and survive when supporting them wins politicians seats.
Why the price keeps falling
Once production gets going, the rest starts to run by itself. Every time the world's total output of solar panels has doubled, the price has fallen by about a fifth. Repeated from 1958 to today, that took solar from more than $3,000 a watt to 12 cents. Lithium-ion battery cells have dropped in price the same way, by about 97 per cent between their launch in 1991 and 2018. Studies of more than 50 technologies have found the same pattern.
The drop in price comes from repetition. Each factory is a little better than the last, and every improvement gets copied across millions of panels.
Not everything gets cheaper this way. Nuclear plants are built one at a time, each a little different, so there's little to repeat. France built more of them, to more standard designs, than almost anyone, and its cost of building them still rose over the decades.
Win on price, quietly
The kettle boils the same on solar power as on coal power, so once solar got cheaper than coal, being cheaper was enough. When the new thing works differently from the old one, it has to be at least as good as well. Electric cars are quick and quiet, you can fill one up at home, and they now go far enough. In 2011 a typical new electric car went about 70 miles on a charge, and by 2024 it went 283 miles. In 2025 more than 20 million were sold around the world, a quarter of all new cars and more than half of China's.
Light bulbs show what happens when the new thing isn't as good. Compact fluorescent bulbs had subsidies and rebates, but they were slow to warm up and their light was harsh, and they stalled at about a third of US sales. LED bulbs came on at full brightness straight away, and could give the same warm light as the old incandescent bulbs. Their price fell 94 per cent between 2008 and 2015, and they took over.
Staying out of the culture war is part of the strategy. A technology that becomes a badge for one side gets resisted by the other, whatever it costs. Electric cars have lagged in the US, where they got tangled up in politics. Fewer than one new car in ten there is electric, against a quarter worldwide. Price and patchy charging explain some of that, but not the gap between the parties. 47 per cent of Democrats say they'd seriously consider one, against only 17 per cent of Republicans.
Alternative protein
Protein made by fermentation comes from yeast or fungi that have been given the gene for a protein from milk, egg or meat, then brewed in big tanks, much like beer. It started where it's worth the most. Impossible Foods uses yeast to make heme, the protein that makes its plant-based burger taste like beef.
Heme makes up only a tiny part of each burger, though, so it can afford to be expensive. The protein people eat most of has to be cheap and made by the tonne, and that's where fermentation is stuck. It can already make the whey in milk and the white of an egg, but not as cheaply as cows and hens do. Sausages and mince would come after that, with fermented proteins and fats blended into them, and steak, a whole cut of muscle, is hardest of all. Like Tesla after the Roadster, fermentation needs bigger factories before it can make something most people will buy.
Beer tanks won't do, because these microbes need air pumped through them and no other microbes in the tank. Most of the tanks that can do that were built for pharmaceuticals, to the rules for making medicine, with clean rooms, staff in gowns and paperwork for every batch. Food doesn't need all of that, but it pays for it when it rents those tanks. The Good Food Institute, an advocacy group for alternative protein, counts only about 16 million litres of food-grade capacity in the world. Whey made this way is the same as whey from milk, so like solar it has to be cheaper to win. So far Vivici, a fermented-whey company part-owned by the New Zealand dairy giant Fonterra, claims only a credible path to matching the price.
The help it needs from a politician is public money to build the first food-grade fermentation plants. The Netherlands is paying for a food-grade line in Ede that opens in 2027, and Australia's federal and Queensland governments have put about A$11 million into upgrading a pilot plant in Mackay. Across every country and all of alternative protein, though, the Good Food Institute counts about $2.5 billion in government funding ever, roughly five times what the US lent Tesla alone.
Whether fermentation gets past this point is open. Its tanks are bigger and more bespoke than solar panels, so its price may fall more slowly. But solar was once a $3,000-a-watt curiosity on a satellite the size of a grapefruit, and it ended up on millions of roofs without anyone having to care about the climate. If fermented protein gets its factories and ends up cheaper than meat, most people will switch the same way, without being persuaded of anything.